2. How the critical evaluation of new and emerging technologies informs design decisions

The following page of notes will cover:

  • Sustainability and environmental issues when designing and making
  • Social, cultural, economic and environmental responsibilities
  • The six Rs of sustainability
  • Life Cycle Analysis (LCA)
  • Fair trade and carbon footprint
  • Ecological footprint


Sustainability and environmental issues

Why Designers Must Consider Them:

  • Most of a product's environmental impact is decided at the design stage
  • Choose renewable, recycled or recyclable materials where possible
  • Use less material and energy in manufacture
  • Design products that last longer and can be repaired
  • Plan for what happens at the end of the product's life

Planned Obsolescence:

  • Designing a product to have a limited life so it has to be replaced

Business Perspectives Consumer/Environmental Impacts
  • Ensures repeat purchases and revenue streams
  • Allows for cheaper initial product pricing
  • Drives continuous innovation cycles
  • Creates excessive e-waste (53 million tonnes/year globally)
  • Exploits consumers through forced upgrades
  • Undermines sustainable design principles

Examples: Smartphone battery sealing, printer ink chip restrictions

Design for Maintenance:

Advantages Disadvantages
  • Extends product lifespan (reduces waste)
  • Modular components enable repairs/upgrades
  • Creates secondary markets for parts
  • Higher initial production costs
  • Requires consumer education
  • Reduces repeat purchase revenue

Examples: Fairphone modular smartphones, Patagonia repair programs


Responsibilities of designers and manufacturers

Responsibility What Designers and Manufacturers Should Consider
Social
  • Safe working conditions and fair pay for workers
  • Inclusive products for all users (e.g. elderly, disabled)
  • Data privacy in smart devices
Cultural
  • Respecting religious beliefs, symbols and colour meanings
  • Avoiding offence or cultural appropriation
Economic
  • Products must be affordable and make a profit
  • Supporting local economies and fair trade
  • Effect of automation on jobs
Environmental
  • Reducing pollution, waste and carbon emissions
  • Using sustainable materials and renewable energy
  • Designing for disassembly and recycling


The six Rs of sustainability

Principle Definition Examples
Rethink Considering alternative, sustainable approaches
  • Using digital documents instead of paper
  • Borrowing instead of buying
  • Choosing sustainable materials
Reuse Using items multiple times instead of disposing
  • Using refillable water bottles
  • Donating old clothes
  • Repurposing glass jars
Recycle Processing materials to make new products
  • Sorting household waste
  • Taking electronics to e-waste centres
  • Buying recycled paper products
Repair Fixing broken items rather than replacing them
  • Sewing torn clothing
  • Fixing electronics
  • Repairing furniture
Reduce Minimising the amount of resources/energy we use
  • Buying products with less packaging
  • Using energy-efficient appliances
  • Printing double-sided
Refuse Saying no to unnecessary items or materials
  • Declining plastic straws
  • Rejecting junk mail
  • Avoiding single-use plastics

Benefits of the six Rs:

  • Reduces waste going to landfill
  • Conserves natural resources
  • Saves energy in production
  • Lowers carbon footprint
  • Saves money in the long term


Life Cycle Analysis (LCA)

  • LCA measures the environmental impact of a product at every stage of its life ("cradle to grave")
  • Used to compare materials and processes and find where impact can be reduced

Stage Impacts Assessed
1. Raw materials Extraction (mining, drilling, logging), energy used, habitat damage
2. Manufacture Energy, water, waste and emissions from processing and making
3. Distribution Packaging and transport (product miles)
4. Use Energy and consumables used, maintenance, lifespan
5. Disposal Landfill, incineration, reuse or recycling

Example: An LCA of a reusable cup vs a disposable cup shows the reusable cup only has lower impact once it has been used many times


Fair trade and carbon footprint

Fair Trade:

  • What It Is: Ethical trading system ensuring fair wages and safe working conditions for producers in developing countries
  • How It Works: Minimum price guarantees plus a premium paid to invest in the community
  • Social: Helps prevent child labour and exploitation
  • Economic: Provides stable incomes for farmers and workers
  • Design Impact: Fairtrade cotton adds 15 to 20% to material costs

Examples: Fairtrade cotton clothing, Fairtrade coffee, Divine Chocolate

Carbon Footprint:

  • The total amount of greenhouse gases (measured as CO₂) released by a product, person or company
  • Released during extraction, manufacture, transport, use and disposal
  • Product mileage: Each transportation stage adds to the carbon footprint through fuel use
  • Reduction Methods: Renewable energy, local materials, less packaging, carbon offsetting


Ecological footprint

  • The area of land and water needed to supply the resources a product (or person) uses and absorb the waste it creates
  • Wider than a carbon footprint: includes land for materials, energy, water and waste

Resource Extraction Environmental Impact
Deforestation
  • Loss of biodiversity
  • Increased CO₂ levels (fewer trees to absorb carbon)
  • Soil erosion
Mining
  • Landscape and habitat destruction
  • Water pollution from runoff
  • Release of toxic chemicals
Drilling
  • Oil spills
  • Water contamination
  • Greenhouse gas emissions
Farming
  • Land use changes
  • Water depletion (e.g. cotton growing)
  • Pesticide/fertiliser runoff

Reducing it: Use fewer and recycled materials, design for long life, source locally



Topic test:

Interactive flashcards:

More from DTBase